Skip to content

Correct TAC filament topology and cytoskeleton parthood - #2286

Merged
realmarcin merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
review-tac-topology-20261012
Oct 12, 2026
Merged

realmarcin merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
review-tac-topology-20261012

Conversation

@realmarcin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Summary

Closes #2284. Closes #2285.

Correct the tripartite attachment complex record after a whole-record scientific review:

  • Exclusion-zone filaments occupy the cytoplasmic basal-body/outer-membrane region; unilateral filaments bridge inner membrane to kDNA.
  • Correct the four spatial graph links and make the nonmechanistic scope visible.
  • Represent cytoskeleton as part_of, not an is-a parent.

Exact GO identity, PROPOSED status, all three protein claims, UNKNOWN essentialities, taxa, old histories and the #769 fixes are preserved. One append-only EDIT accompanies the guarded native write. One semantic embedding was re-encoded offline through the native pinned model helper; 908 other vectors are unchanged. Derived PCA/neighbor files and site copies are regenerated, accounting for the larger generated diff.

Review Lineage

  • Observation: reviews/structured/20261012T045744Z-tac-filament-topology-and-parthood/review.yaml and review.md (F1/F2).
  • Resolution: reviews/structured/20261012T052500Z-tac-topology-and-parthood-resolved/review.yaml and review.md.
  • Stable keys: tac-filament-compartment-reversal, tac-cytoskeleton-is-a-versus-part-of.

Same-agent review and curation, not independent human sign-off. Ogbadoyi Methods/Results/Discussion and Figures2/6, TAC40 Results/Discussion/Methods, TAC102 relevant Results/Discussion/Methods and its republication notice were inspected. Zhao reading was limited to the complete primary abstract and early full-page localization/RNAi Results before an access challenge. Full limitations are in the immutable bundles. No raw-data reanalysis or new measurement.

Verification

  • Fresh full local QC: 987 passed, 3 skipped in 810.43s (0:13:30); 909 strict records and 1724 histories.
  • Direct target schema/strict/snippet checks, live global authority/trait checks, canonical archive and patch-preservation assertions passed.
  • The original observation, all older bundles and all 62 pre-existing untracked reports are unchanged.
  • The three other source-gathering targets remain pending, not counted as complete.
  • Require all four PR and all four native merge-group gates; no bypass.

@realmarcin realmarcin left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Adversarial Review

Same-agent review of the exact PR head, not an independent reviewer or human scientific sign-off.

No additional actionable findings. The two pre-curation major findings are tracked in #2284 and #2285 and have explicit immutable successor dispositions.

Checks applied:

  • Challenged the compartment assignment against the defining Ogbadoyi Results, Methods and Discussion and inspected Figure 2 ultrastructure and Figure 6 schematic. Exclusion-zone filaments are cytoplasmic; unilateral filaments connect inner membrane to kDNA. The corrected four-link chain matches those distinct regions.
  • Checked that this did not become a temporal assembly or protein-level force-transfer claim. The native NONMECHANISTIC classification and displayed spatial-linkage caveat remain explicit. The last two graph edges, node identifiers and component references are preserved.
  • Checked GO relation direction against the live cytoskeleton child relation and the local schema contract. The change is part_of, not a reversed edge or a guessed new is-a parent. Exact GO:0120121 identity is unchanged.
  • Compared the entire corrected YAML with the pre-curation record. Protein roles, UNKNOWN assembly essentialities, label-only groundings, taxonomic scope, canonical example, function, discussion, PROPOSED status and earlier #769 fixes are preserved.
  • Verified generated HTML exposes both corrected compartments, the proper edge endpoints and Part of relation. No generated page was manually edited.
  • Audited the larger generated diff: exactly one record embedding was re-encoded offline with the repository's pinned model/helper; the other 908 vector records and model metadata are unchanged. PCA and neighbor outputs, including site copies, were regenerated and passed native drift checks.
  • Verified append-only inline/repository EDIT history, unchanged predecessor review, exact F1/F2 resolution lineage and preservation of all older bundles and 62 pre-existing untracked reports. Only the scoped 12 publication paths are staged/committed.
  • Fresh full native QC, direct record checks, authority/trait checks, immutable archive checks and targeted preservation assertions passed. Required PR and native merge-group gates remain mandatory; this review does not waive them.

Limits: Zhao was read at complete primary abstract plus early full-page localization/RNAi Results scope before a challenge, not complete Methods. No raw image reanalysis or new quantitative measurement. Other pending source-gathering records are not counted complete by this PR.

@realmarcin
realmarcin added this pull request to the merge queue Oct 12, 2026
Merged via the queue into main with commit 937ba62 Oct 12, 2026
4 checks passed
@realmarcin
realmarcin deleted the review-tac-topology-20261012 branch October 12, 2026 05:47
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Represent cytoskeleton as TAC parthood instead of an is-a parent Restore the correct TAC filament compartments and bridge order

1 participant