Description
signInSilently() can never report success. The silent sign-in URL is built with
state: "sign-in-silently", but getAuthorizeRequestUrlParams replaces the caller's
state with instance_<instanceId> whenever an instance ID is present — and
getSignInUrl always passes one. The authorize request goes out with
state=instance_0_request_N, so the hidden iframe never recognises the IdP's
response as a silent sign-in, never posts the code to the parent, and the parent's
10 s timeout resolves false.
The override was introduced in 10ca5ed ("Refactor instance ID handling in authorization
flow and update state parameter format") and is still present on main (3487684).
Root cause
- The silent sign-in URL asks for the silent state
(main-thread-client.ts#L325-L330,
same in web-worker-client.ts#L420-L426):
_authenticationClient.getSignInUrl({ prompt: 'none', state: SILENT_SIGN_IN_STATE, ...additionalParams })
getSignInUrl always passes an instance ID
(legacy/client.ts#L288):
instanceId: this.getInstanceId().toString() — "0" for the default instance, which is truthy.
getAuthorizeRequestUrlParams then discards the caller's state
(getAuthorizeRequestUrlParams.ts#L101-L121).
state is skipped in the customParams loop (L103), and the only branch that would
use it is unreachable when instanceId is set:
if (options.instanceId) {
customStateValue = AUTH_INSTANCE_PREFIX + options.instanceId; // always taken
} else if (customParams) {
customStateValue = customParams[OIDCRequestConstants.Params.STATE]?.toString() ?? ''; // never reached
}
- In the iframe, the response is only treated as a silent sign-in if the state contains the marker
(session-management-helper.ts#L178,
spa-utils.ts#L152-L156):
state.includes(SILENT_SIGN_IN_STATE) is false, so nothing is posted to the parent, and the parent
resolves false on its timeout
(authentication-helper.ts#L574).
The check-session prompt-none request passes state: STATE the same way
(session-management-helper.ts#L158),
so syncSession looks affected by the same override (not verified at runtime).
Expected
The authorize request carries a state containing sign-in-silently; the iframe posts
the code to the parent, the parent exchanges it, and the promise resolves with the user.
Actual
Captured with the Chrome DevTools Protocol:
- The
/oauth2/authorize?prompt=none request carries the IdP session cookies
(commonAuthId, opbs, SameSite=None) — none excluded, so this is not
third-party-cookie blocking.
- The IdP answers
302 Location: <afterSignInUrl>?code=…&session_state=…&state=instance_0_request_1.
- The iframe loads
afterSignInUrl with that code. Nothing is posted to the parent,
the parent makes no token request, and signInSilently() resolves false ~10 s later.
Side effect: because afterSignInUrl is the app itself, the app boots inside the iframe
and shares the tab's sessionStorage. Its AsgardeoProvider then either
- sees
isSignedIn() true and ignores the code (nothing is renewed), or
- runs a normal
signIn() and exchanges the code itself (token request initiated from
signIn), so the session is renewed — while the parent still gets false.
An app that treats false as "session lost" therefore asks the user to sign in again
even when it now holds valid tokens.
Suggested fix
Keep both parts instead of letting the instance prefix replace the caller's state:
const instanceState = options.instanceId ? AUTH_INSTANCE_PREFIX + options.instanceId : '';
const callerState = customParams?.[OIDCRequestConstants.Params.STATE]?.toString() ?? '';
const customStateValue = [instanceState, callerState].filter(Boolean).join('_');
This yields e.g. instance_0_sign-in-silently_request_0, which still satisfies
hasCalledForThisInstanceInUrl (state=instance_<id>_[^&]+) and
state.includes(SILENT_SIGN_IN_STATE) / state.includes(STATE).
A regression test for getSignInUrl({ prompt: 'none', state: 'sign-in-silently' })
with instance ID 0 asserting the marker survives would cover it.
Related: #527 (no on-demand refresh-token use when the access token has expired).
Steps to Reproduce
- React SPA with
<AsgardeoProvider>, default config (sessionStorage, PKCE on),
afterSignInUrl set to the app's own origin (e.g. http://localhost:3000).
- Sign in normally.
- Call
signInSilently() from useAsgardeo() and inspect the network.
- Observe the authorize request's
state=instance_0_request_N (no sign-in-silently),
the IdP's 302 with a code into the hidden iframe, and the promise resolving false
after ~10 s.
Please select the area the issue is related to
@asgardeo/javascript, @asgardeo/browser, @asgardeo/react
Version
@asgardeo/react 0.25.14 (@asgardeo/browser 0.7.17, @asgardeo/javascript 0.23.6); also reproduced on @asgardeo/react 0.22.4 (@asgardeo/browser 0.6.6, @asgardeo/javascript 0.18.0). Present on main at 3487684.
Environment Details (with versions)
macOS 26.6.2, Chrome 154.0.8037.93, React 19.2.3.
Reporter Checklist
Description
signInSilently()can never report success. The silent sign-in URL is built withstate: "sign-in-silently", butgetAuthorizeRequestUrlParamsreplaces the caller'sstate with
instance_<instanceId>whenever an instance ID is present — andgetSignInUrlalways passes one. The authorize request goes out withstate=instance_0_request_N, so the hidden iframe never recognises the IdP'sresponse as a silent sign-in, never posts the code to the parent, and the parent's
10 s timeout resolves
false.The override was introduced in 10ca5ed ("Refactor instance ID handling in authorization
flow and update state parameter format") and is still present on
main(3487684).Root cause
(main-thread-client.ts#L325-L330,
same in web-worker-client.ts#L420-L426):
getSignInUrlalways passes an instance ID(legacy/client.ts#L288):
instanceId: this.getInstanceId().toString()—"0"for the default instance, which is truthy.getAuthorizeRequestUrlParamsthen discards the caller's state(getAuthorizeRequestUrlParams.ts#L101-L121).
stateis skipped in thecustomParamsloop (L103), and the only branch that woulduse it is unreachable when
instanceIdis set:(session-management-helper.ts#L178,
spa-utils.ts#L152-L156):
state.includes(SILENT_SIGN_IN_STATE)is false, so nothing is posted to the parent, and the parentresolves
falseon its timeout(authentication-helper.ts#L574).
The check-session prompt-none request passes
state: STATEthe same way(session-management-helper.ts#L158),
so
syncSessionlooks affected by the same override (not verified at runtime).Expected
The authorize request carries a state containing
sign-in-silently; the iframe poststhe code to the parent, the parent exchanges it, and the promise resolves with the user.
Actual
Captured with the Chrome DevTools Protocol:
/oauth2/authorize?prompt=nonerequest carries the IdP session cookies(
commonAuthId,opbs,SameSite=None) — none excluded, so this is notthird-party-cookie blocking.
302 Location: <afterSignInUrl>?code=…&session_state=…&state=instance_0_request_1.afterSignInUrlwith that code. Nothing is posted to the parent,the parent makes no token request, and
signInSilently()resolvesfalse~10 s later.Side effect: because
afterSignInUrlis the app itself, the app boots inside the iframeand shares the tab's sessionStorage. Its
AsgardeoProviderthen eitherisSignedIn()true and ignores the code (nothing is renewed), orsignIn()and exchanges the code itself (token request initiated fromsignIn), so the session is renewed — while the parent still getsfalse.An app that treats
falseas "session lost" therefore asks the user to sign in againeven when it now holds valid tokens.
Suggested fix
Keep both parts instead of letting the instance prefix replace the caller's state:
This yields e.g.
instance_0_sign-in-silently_request_0, which still satisfieshasCalledForThisInstanceInUrl(state=instance_<id>_[^&]+) andstate.includes(SILENT_SIGN_IN_STATE)/state.includes(STATE).A regression test for
getSignInUrl({ prompt: 'none', state: 'sign-in-silently' })with instance ID
0asserting the marker survives would cover it.Related: #527 (no on-demand refresh-token use when the access token has expired).
Steps to Reproduce
<AsgardeoProvider>, default config (sessionStorage, PKCE on),afterSignInUrlset to the app's own origin (e.g.http://localhost:3000).signInSilently()fromuseAsgardeo()and inspect the network.state=instance_0_request_N(nosign-in-silently),the IdP's 302 with a code into the hidden iframe, and the promise resolving
falseafter ~10 s.
Please select the area the issue is related to
@asgardeo/javascript, @asgardeo/browser, @asgardeo/react
Version
@asgardeo/react0.25.14 (@asgardeo/browser0.7.17,@asgardeo/javascript0.23.6); also reproduced on@asgardeo/react0.22.4 (@asgardeo/browser0.6.6,@asgardeo/javascript0.18.0). Present onmainat 3487684.Environment Details (with versions)
macOS 26.6.2, Chrome 154.0.8037.93, React 19.2.3.
Reporter Checklist