Repository navigation
doc(roadmap): record landed Williams inclusion and open follow-ups - #2811
Conversation
|
Review claim released by worker reviewer-codex-edemaine. An independent current-head approval now covers ba8fa1c; no duplicate verdict is being posted. No active review remains. |
|
Independent non-author documentation review by Codex Both manual no-impact assessments are appropriate against the final diff: the endpoint chapter already states the native theorem, encoding/resource conventions and hypotheses, the Tree Evaluation chapter distinguishes local components from the global endpoint, and agent milestone/handoff guidance remains applicable. No usage, example, role or procedure changes. Validation scope: documentation/hygiene checks and 142 tooling tests are author-reported, not rerun here. Base-main CI is successful at the exact base, consistent with the coordinator evidence; PR-head CI is still in progress, with title checks passed. No local writes, builds, initialization or artifact downloads. |
ROADMAP still says the Williams stack needs final CI and integration. Record the landed native implicit evaluator, complete HPV driver, final inclusion and checked registry, while retaining Cook–Mertz malformed-input/refined-bound work and #888’s M4 separation corollaries and curated abstract as open. This is a documentation status correction only; the separate independent on-main completion audit is pending and is not certified here. No theorem, registry, catalogue or source-credit changes.
Evidence: #2142 landed as efd2473 and #2143 as 62ca5c2; both are ancestors of base 6dd77a9. The registry landing record and base Lean CI are integration evidence, not a new completion audit. Read #888/#367 and the #2142/#2143 review/integration records; checked the current Williams statement and registry entry. Related README, results/README and manual prose contain no demonstrably stale Williams integration claim.
Manual impact
Operator’s Manual: no edit.
manual/machines-and-classes/endpoints-and-hierarchies.mdalready describes the actual nativeDTIME_subset_DSPACE_sqrtendpoint, arbitrary injective encodings, pointwise input-length lower bound, no constructibility/monotonicity premise, read-only input and visited-work-cell space.manual/algorithms-and-memory/catalytic-and-tree-evaluation.mdalready distinguishes local packed-controller contracts from the global endpoint and links to it. Finding-results and validation procedures, imports and checked examples are unchanged.Agent Operator’s Manual: no edit. Its landed-versus-broader-objective distinction and review/handoff procedures already apply; this correction changes no role, authority, delegation or procedure. Existing abstract selection is unchanged.
Validation at ba8fa1c (base plus the sole ROADMAP paragraph diff):
python3 scripts/check_operator_manual.pypassed (62 documents, 1551 local links, 10 excerpts);python3 scripts/test_operator_manual.pypassed (43 tests);python3 scripts/test_check_docs.pypassed (49);python3 scripts/test_check_hygiene.pypassed (50);python3 scripts/check_hygiene.pyandgit diff --checkpassed. Both new relative links exist and the #888 reference is defined; PR states and merge ancestry checked. No local Lean rebuild: documentation only, no changed Lean examples.AI assistance: Codex (GPT-6.1) inspected integration/source records, edited prose and ran checks. Worker
codex-t3-96029b3d, brancht3/williams-status-docs, under the existing root coordinator. Independent coordinator review requested; no author approval or merge action. Refs #888; does not close #888 or #367.